Icon

Time to think about some stuff guys!

1: tanks/healers/dps
2: raiding days, 2/3/4?
3: raidleader/co-raidleader
4: ranks(officers)
5: lootrules

1. I think Harder will only ever want to be tank spec, not sure about Wheiler. Dunno about Murloc tanks though?
2. I'd say stick to 3 days, and my personal preference is Wed/Sun/Mon but I'm open on that issue.
3. Good question, who is main rl in Murloc?
4. We need a good trim here, lots to be removed I think.
5. Prefer to stick with loot council, it's fair and has worked for us for many years.

1. I can go tank or melee doesnt really matter for me its all up to the other tank( might rethink this later on closer to next expac but that aint 25man)
2. agree on 3 days a week
3. Up to you guys
4. agree with hog
5. both groups uses loot council atm but use a slighly different style of it to much talk during loot otherwise

Time to think about some stuff guys!

1: Scummy is maintank in Murloc and I think he wants to stay tank.
2: 3, I prefer wed/sun/mon. Like we have atm with Murloc team. From 19:45 (invites) till 23:00ish
3: I don't really care. Currently in Murloc it's Maxi, Egam or Me leading.
4: We need to cut down in officer rank I think. I don't care about my rank, I'll do the same stuff in raids anyway. Can't seem to shut up.
5: Don't really like the current system. I still prefer some kind of simple DKP system.

1: we might ahve too much healers too.
2:can't say for myself till uni doesn't start again but i think that wen/sun/mon will be good(but some pople can't play on sun)
3:well we should make 2-3 officer to rl adn theh just they sor it out.
4.agree on cut of officers
5.there is nothing simple bout dkp

Demoted myself on forum to social :) feel free to demote my toons ingame

#9116087 Tootheater wrote:

5.there is nothing simple bout dkp

Well, I used a very simple DKP system when I was in CAE. We gave everybody 10dkp for joining raid (also the benched ppl if they stay online till end of raid). When an item dropped the person with most dkp had first choise and he would pay half his dkp for the item (OS items was like 5dkp). Mainspec has prio of course.
The more you raid, more dkp, more chance on loot. If somebody got an item he will drop below the others, so the next person will get next loot, unless perhaps a person haven't got loot in weeks, it would be possible to get 2 items. But that's fair too because another person might have had 2 or 3 items in the previous raids.

We kept track of dkp in ppl's note. No addon required and all officers/RL's can update note. All you need to do is write down raiders names to update it at end of raid or during loot distribution.

1: How many we need of each? I guess 2 tanks (with 1 or 2 off-spec tanks) & 4-5 healers (with 2 or 3 off spec healers) I'd say we probably want 30 or so raiders total?

2: I think most favour 3. For me personally, only issue is that I can only raid 2 nights ( I know there are others like me) so what does that mean for DKP & standby duty?

3: raidleader/co-raidleader - Maybe we should make them audition for the job. They should sing a song on youtube or something? :p

4: ranks(officers) - Agree we have too many, personally I'm happy to be demoted I do nothing anyway :p I think we should assign officers to roles so we know who to come to for what and we spread the workload more fairly.
maybe 1 officer for recruitment, 1 for bank management, 1 for discipline etc

5: lootrules - I like loot council, but DKP is OK too

#9119062 Bulligan wrote:

[quote_post9116087 user=865031]

Well, I used a very simple DKP system when I was in CAE. We gave everybody 10dkp for joining raid (also the benched ppl if they stay online till end of raid). When an item dropped the person with most dkp had first choise and he would pay half his dkp for the item (OS items was like 5dkp). Mainspec has prio of course.
The more you raid, more dkp, more chance on loot. If somebody got an item he will drop below the others, so the next person will get next loot, unless perhaps a person haven't got loot in weeks, it would be possible to get 2 items. But that's fair too because another person might have had 2 or 3 items in the previous raids.

We kept track of dkp in ppl's note. No addon required and all officers/RL's can update note. All you need to do is write down raiders names to update it at end of raid or during loot distribution.

Ye but then persons with offspecs will never use dkp to get os items(even if its only 5 dkp) they would rather save so they can be top on dkp for next week so that 1 trinket is for them for sure(or isnter any random item insted of trinket).

Tanks:
-Harder
-Scummy
-Wheiler (os dps)
-Zeross (os dps)

Healers:
-Suker
-Bulli
-Maxi
-Glylyna
-???????
-???????

DPS:
-Hog
-Égam
-Tooth (os healer)
-Eddio
-Elder (os tank)
-Zagrat
-Emyrus
-Bekman
-Mazzura
-Uahafa
-Zatrix (os tank)
-Meccero
-Glmod
-Rysler (os healer)
-Sombra
-Rassler
-Ciocolax
-Nikeehunt

GM:
-Hog
-Égam

RaidLeader: (Tactics & Execution during raid)
-Hog
-Égam

RaidCD (calls during raid)
-Healer

Officers:
-(Tank)
-(Healer)
-(DPS)
(Officers take care of the performance of people with the same role and decide loot distribution. 1 of each role)

(ps, change/add stuff to this list)

That sounds great

#9115907 Hogarella wrote:

1. I think Harder will only ever want to be tank spec, not sure about Wheiler. Dunno about Murloc tanks though?
2. I'd say stick to 3 days, and my personal preference is Wed/Sun/Mon but I'm open on that issue.
3. Good question, who is main rl in Murloc?
4. We need a good trim here, lots to be removed I think.
5. Prefer to stick with loot council, it's fair and has worked for us for many years.

1. I agree whit hog. My dps sucks!!!
2. Thos days are good.
3.???
4. No coment.i can do the guild bank if thats ok.
5. I do a gree on loot council.

U can even put me into ms healer if neededa and i think rysler is ms healer

Anyone checked if tactics are much different in 25man? How is dark shamans done for example?

I can check that but i have feeling u won't want me raid leading xD.

I want you raid leading toothy.
Don't be afraid to volunteer. I know we all take the piss, but you're actually pretty good at it.